SC CJ warns AI can't replace human qualities in justice

Chief Justice Alexander Gesmundo has warned that while artificial intelligence (AI) can streamline judicial processes, it should never replace the essential human qualities needed to ensure fair and compassionate justice.

During his speech at the 19th Conference of Chief Justices in Kuala Lumpur on October 12, 2024, Gesmundo emphasized the importance of empathy and ethical discretion in granting equitable remedies.

Gesmundo acknowledged AI's potential to assist with administrative tasks, legal research, and predicting judicial outcomes but stressed that human oversight is crucial for maintaining justice integrity.

He also discussed the Strategic Plan for Judicial Innovations 2022-2027, which aims to integrate AI into court processes to improve efficiency and access to justice while upholding ethical standards.

Gesmundo highlighted examples from foreign jurisdictions where AI is used in courts for tasks such as examining evidence and preparing case files.

The Supreme Court stressed the need for judicial institutions to navigate rapid technological changes responsibly, ensuring that technology supports rather than replaces human judges.